Home / Docs / Diagnostics

U3016: Second-class type used as a type argument

Release v0.4.0

A function type with uses or fails instantiates a type parameter. U3016 points at the written type argument, or at the value whose type instantiates the type parameter.

Why Una rejects it

A function type with uses or fails is second-class (spec/05 §6, ADR 0038 D2). It may be the type of a parameter, so an effectful or failing function can be passed directly as a call argument and called there. But it can never instantiate a type parameter:

A value of type T can be bound, stored or returned, so a second-class type in its place would carry authority out of the with scope where it was created.

How to fix it

Pass the function directly to the function that calls it, with a parameter of function type.

The repair at a glance

diff
  module demo

  capability Log
    op write(line: Text) -> Unit

- id[T](x: T) -> T = x
-
  note(line: Text) -> Unit
    uses @log: Log[write]
  =
    @log.write(line)

  run(write: fn(Text) -> Unit uses @log: Log[write]) -> Unit
    uses @log: Log[write]
  =
    write("hello")

  pub main() -> Unit
    uses @log: Log[write]
  =
-   run(id(note))
+   run(note)

Failing example

una
module demo

capability Log
  op write(line: Text) -> Unit

id[T](x: T) -> T = x

note(line: Text) -> Unit
  uses @log: Log[write]
=
  @log.write(line)

run(write: fn(Text) -> Unit uses @log: Log[write]) -> Unit
  uses @log: Log[write]
=
  write("hello")

pub main() -> Unit
  uses @log: Log[write]
=
  run(id(note))

Fixed example

una
module demo

capability Log
  op write(line: Text) -> Unit

note(line: Text) -> Unit
  uses @log: Log[write]
=
  @log.write(line)

run(write: fn(Text) -> Unit uses @log: Log[write]) -> Unit
  uses @log: Log[write]
=
  write("hello")

pub main() -> Unit
  uses @log: Log[write]
=
  run(note)