---
title: "U3033: An operation of `HttpServer` in the effect set of a `together` branch, a `together for` body, a `first of` branch, or `handle` or `on_stop` of a `serve` module"
url: https://una-lang.org/en/docs/errors/U3033/
release: v0.4.0
source: https://github.com/una-lang/una/blob/v0.4.0/crates/una-explain/explain/U3033.md
---

# U3033: An operation of `HttpServer` in the effect set of a `together` branch, a `together for` body, a `first of` branch, or `handle` or `on_stop` of a `serve` module

An operation of `HttpServer` is in the effect set of a branch of `together`, a body of `together for` or a branch of `first of`, or `handle` or `on_stop` of a `serve` module names `HttpServer` in its `uses`.

## Why Una rejects it

The branches of `together`, the bodies of `together for` and the branches of `first of` run at once and act for the one task that runs the construct (`spec/19 §1`, `spec/27 §6`). A reply right of `HttpServer` is held by one task at a time (ADR 0123 rule 4), so two branches that could both answer it would answer in an order that timing decides.

The effect set of a branch therefore MUST NOT contain an operation of `HttpServer`: `next`, `reply` or `close` (`spec/31 §1`, ADR 0123 rule 5). This holds for an operation performed:

- in the branch;
- by a function it calls or names;
- by a function value whose type's requirements hold `HttpServer`;
- by a handler it installs;
- by an operation whose handler can perform one;
- or, in a program that imports a name of the server, by a `uses of` parameter that it calls or passes on, whose code its callers choose.

The error is at the operation, the call, the function value or the installation.

The same holds for `handle` and `on_stop` of the module that the `serve` section of `ita.una` names (`spec/31 §7`, ADR 0123 rule 16). In that form the host owns every exchange and answers each request with the reply `handle` returns, so neither function may name `HttpServer`, or a capability whose handlers can perform one of its operations, in its `uses`. The error is at the binding.

## How to fix it

- In a branch, the repair is to compute in the branches and to answer after the construct.
- In `handle` and `on_stop`, the repair is to return the reply from `handle`, or to write the server in the language form, with `next` in a `for ever` loop and no `serve` section.

## The repair at a glance

`src/demo.una`

```diff
  module demo

  import std.host (Exchange, HttpServer, Reply)

  price(n: internal Int) -> internal Int = n * 3

  answer(exchange: internal Exchange, n: internal Int) -> Unit
    uses @server: HttpServer[reply]
  =
    together
      let total = price(n)
-     let sent = @server.reply(to: exchange.right, reply: Reply(status: 204, headers: [], body: ""))
-       if error use unit
-   unit
+     let tax = price(n + 1)
+   @server.reply(to: exchange.right, reply: Reply(status: 200, headers: [], body: "{total + tax}"))
+     if error use unit
```

## Failing example

`ita.una`

```una
ita demo
  version 0.1.0
  edition 0.4
```

`ita.lock`

```una
lock 1

solver
  encoding "una-smt-1"
  name "z3"
  version "5.1.0"
  logic "QF_UFLIA"
  steps 5000000
  seed 0
```

`src/demo.una`

```una
module demo

import std.host (Exchange, HttpServer, Reply)

price(n: internal Int) -> internal Int = n * 3

answer(exchange: internal Exchange, n: internal Int) -> Unit
  uses @server: HttpServer[reply]
=
  together
    let total = price(n)
    let sent = @server.reply(to: exchange.right, reply: Reply(status: 204, headers: [], body: ""))
      if error use unit
  unit
```

## Fixed example

`ita.una`

```una
ita demo
  version 0.1.0
  edition 0.4
```

`ita.lock`

```una
lock 1

solver
  encoding "una-smt-1"
  name "z3"
  version "5.1.0"
  logic "QF_UFLIA"
  steps 5000000
  seed 0
```

`src/demo.una`

```una
module demo

import std.host (Exchange, HttpServer, Reply)

price(n: internal Int) -> internal Int = n * 3

answer(exchange: internal Exchange, n: internal Int) -> Unit
  uses @server: HttpServer[reply]
=
  together
    let total = price(n)
    let tax = price(n + 1)
  @server.reply(to: exchange.right, reply: Reply(status: 200, headers: [], body: "{total + tax}"))
    if error use unit
```
